Tags
banned book, banned book week, book review, fantasy, MG, MG series
Author: C. S. Lewis
Published: Originally, 1950
Publisher:Harper Collins
Age group | Genre: MG | Fantasy
Pages: 206
Sometimes, it hurts my heart when a book is challenged or banned. The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe is one of those times. Underneath the deeper, allegorical side to this novel, there lies a beautiful fantasy story that will literally open up worlds for children. Of the banned books over the years, I desperately hate the fact that this is one of them. I feel the censorship of this story hides imagination and friends that readers will never find anywhere else.
Summary
“Narnia… the land beyond the wardrobe, the secret country known only to Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy…the place where the adventure begins.
Lucy is the first to find the secret of the wardrobe in the professor’s mysterious old house. At first, no one believes her when she tells of her adventures in the land of Narnia. But soon Edmund and then Peter and Susan discover the Magic and meet Aslan, the Great Lion, for themselves. In the blink of an eye, their lives are changed forever”
source – book jacket
Why It’s Been Banned
* possibe spoilers
The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe was banned in 1990 for depicting graphic violence, mysticism, and gore. And in 2005, when Jed Bush picked it for a required reading book in Florida, and the novel was viewed as not politically correct for school reading. In fact, it was deemed “unconstitutional” by the Americans for the Separation of Church and State because Aslan can be interpreted as a Christ-like figure and offensive to non-Christians.
My Thoughts
My mother read this novel to me as a young child, and we even had the BBC TV mini-series version where people actually dressed up like wolves. I loved the story so much I wore out the VHS. Because I grew up in a church, my mom pointed out the allegorical side of The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe when we read it… but as a child, all I did was search for the wardrobe. In fact, I was convinced my closet would take me to Narnia. I can understand the issue between church and state for some people, but honestly, this story can be as much of a story as it can be analyzed and ripped apart in symbolism. Narnia opened up worlds for me as a child, and I would not have the imagination I do today would it not be for this series. I reread the Chronicles of Narnia two summers ago, and it wasn’t until then, when I was 23, that I really saw the deep symbolism of the stories. This is a book that can be taught to inspire the imagination without ever having to analyze themes for children.
If you like The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe you might like….
- The Chronicles of Narnia Series by C.S. Lewis: The Magician’s Nephew, The Horse and his Boy, Prince Caspian, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, The Silver Chair, The Last Battle
- The Underland Chronicles by Suzanne Collins
- The Inkworld Trilogy by Cornelia Funke
Book Talk: Where do you stand with The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe ban? Do you think it’s tame enough for a middle school classroom or too scandalous? Have you read the rest of the series? Just as good or better? Should they be banned?
Hopeful reading!
Elisabeth (YS Princess) said:
I agree – how sad it is that this lovely book was challenged!
Stopping by from Follow Friday 🙂
caitlore said:
Thanks for stopping by!
Kelly said:
I never even knew there was an allegory to this book (and series) until I was an adult. It was literally a beautiful, sad and joyful fantasy to me as a child. My sister-in-law reintroduced it to me when she gave the series to my daughter when she was in fourth grade. I started reading the whole series at that time and it was the first time I had ever put all the symbolism together. This novel is definitely tame enough for the middle school classroom and up! It takes a while to get through the whole series though. A couple of them definitely take perserverance to get through, but well worth it in the end.
caitlore said:
And if it hadn’t been for your love of the pure story… I would have never fallen in love with it!
Thanks Mom!
Liesel Hill said:
Great post! I feel the same way! My mom read this to me as a child and when I got to college, I read the Chronicles in their entirety and loved them all! I take serious issue with the Aslan excuse, not only because I’m a Christian, but because it’s such a double standard. Kids read plenty of atheistic-ish novels in school, and if Christians even give a whimper about it, we’re reamed! But if there’s even a remote possibility that something in a story kinda sorta maybe on some obscure level smacks of religion, they ban it. Really? As you said, that interpretation is purely allegorical, and the student/parent/teacher can use any interpretation they want. By banning it, all they’re doing is drawing more attention to that aspect of the text, not less. Anyway, sorry for the novel-long response. Obviously this is a pet peeve of mine. I really appreciate your post, though. Happy Friday! 😀
caitlore said:
Love your response! I completely agree with the double standard. As a Christian, I do often read this book from my faith, and there are others I read that way too…. but as you said, they can be un-read that way and simply enjoyed for the fantasy. But there are so many other books out there that point fingers and pick at Christians, yet, one little word and we are “put in our place” because of out faith.
I guess that’s why I keep reading and promoting books. Because someday, somewhere, a good book WILL make a difference in a child’s life.
picturemereading said:
Someone referred me to your blog and I love your drawings..I am an artist as well..love to meet another artistically inclined blogger 🙂 I added you via wordpress 🙂
caitlore said:
Oh thank you! I’m not all that artistically inclined… my husband does the fancy drawing and I just trace everything. Though, I’m pretty great at drawing books….:)
Thanks for the follow!
picturemereading said:
It’s cool that you and your husband work together on your blog 🙂
Jackie Crawford said:
I loved “The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe” and my kids did too. It makes me sad that great books like these are challenged, when it’s some of the most creative writing out there. They just read another great book that I’d like to recommend if you all are interested, I think it’s a similar concept! It’s called “Dr. Fuddle and the Gold Baton” by Warren L. Woodruff, you can check it out and get it right from the website http://www.drfuddle.com/. Great post, glad there are others out there who really appreciate classic work!
caitlore said:
I’ve never heard of that book, but it sounds wonderful! Thank you for the suggestion, and thanks for stopping by!!
Classic Children’s literature always wins me over 😉
Pingback: 9 great kids’ books you didn’t know were banned | BabyNowUSA
Pingback: 9 great kids’ books you didn’t know were banned | Great Book MallGreat Book Mall